'The List of Suspicious Things' by Jennie Godfrey

16 July 2025

Jennie Godfrey's debut novel 'The List of Suspicious Things' draws on her own childhood in West Yorkshire in the 1970s. It has a lot of similarities to ‘The Trouble with Goats and Sheep’ (reviewed here in January 2022) by Joanna Cannon (who is thanked by Godfrey in the acknowledgements). Both books are mostly narrated in the first person by a young girl who sets out, with her best friend, to solve a mystery that neither of them really understands. In 'The List of Suspicious Things' the naive protagonist, Miv, is slightly older than Grace (in ‘The Trouble with Goats and Sheep’) and the mystery she is obsessed by is the real-world horrific killings by the Yorkshire Ripper. Jennie Godfrey makes Miv a very likeable, entertaining and amusing central presence, and creates a lovely core cast of warm, sympathetic characters. The light comic tone sometimes feels awkward alongside the extremely dark happenings. And the novel suffers a little from first-book-syndrome, trying to pack in too many themes and shocking events. But it's a very engaging story which really conjures up the period and the challenges of childhood interrupted by tragedy.