Cultural Dessert

 

Whenever I hear a comic song I always think of Harris: "Well, you don't look for much of a voice in a comic song. You don't expect correct phrasing or vocalisation. You don't mind if a man does find out, when in the middle of a note, that he is too high, and comes down with a jerk. You don't bother about time. You don't mind a man being two bars in front of the accompaniment, and easing up in the middle of a line to argue it out with the pianist, and then starting the verse afresh. But you do expect the words." ('Three Men in a Boat' by Jerome K. Jerome, 1889) Australian comedian Tim Minchin is a modern master of the comic song (and has no problem remembering the words!). We had heard a lot about Tim Minchin at the Edinburgh Fringe but we hadn't managed to see his show so we took the opportunity last Saturday to see him closer to home at The Stables at Wavendon. Every time we go to The Stables I get nervous, as we enter the car park, that we're going to be part of a select few - it's a big auditorium that can often look embarrassingly empty. On Saturday I was relieved to see the car park stewards at full stretch to pack us in: it was almost a full house and clearly most of the audience were already much more familiar with Tim Minchin than we were. There were cheers of recognition at the beginning of most of his songs and plenty of people singing along. To his credit Minchin didn't play on this adulation, treating each lyrical 'reveal' as if it was the first time he had sung it. He is a brilliant pianist - demonstrating some of the most amazing boogie woogie piano playing I've seen. And he incorporates a wide range of musical styles/pastiches. I'm very wary of sounding a critical note given the vitriolic revenge Tim Minchin took on a savage review by the Guardian journalist Daoust, which is now an integral part of his show - but actually that song is a good case in point. Maybe I'm just getting old, but it seems a shame that much of Minchin's witty wordplay and excellent observational humour is undermined by resorting to unnecessary bad language to generate a cheap laugh. Modern stand-up comedy seems to have established a culture where it cannot be edgy and cool unless it involves swearing. Tim Minchin is by no means the worst offender but I think he'll be much funnier when he gets his own Radio 4 series and has to ditch the bad language.