10 April 2026
Francis Spufford's debut novel ‘Golden Hill’ (reviewed here in August 2017) remains one of my favourite books - a brilliant tour de force set in Manhattan in 1746: beautifully written, historically fascinating with wonderfully drawn characters and a mesmeric plot. He has followed 'Golden Hill' with three more historical novels, each set in a different period and each exploring different literary genres and setting himself increasingly ambitious narrative challenges. None has been as satisfying as 'Golden Hill', but 'Light Perpetual' (reviewed here in July 2021) and ‘Cahokia Jazz’ (reviewed here in February 2024) were both fascinating and beautifully written. In his fourth novel 'Nonesuch' (which I have just finished reading as an unabridged audio book, narrated by Lydia Wilson) Francis Spufford steps into the world of fantasy. Set in London in the early years of World War II, from the start it is clear that this is going to be a realistically described London but also one in which magic is present - reminding me of Ben Aaronovitch’s ‘Rivers of London’ novels (reviewed here in June 2018 and August 2022). 'Nonesuch' starts brilliantly and grippingly, as well as being wonderfully laced together with Francis Spufford's beautiful descriptive phrases. But as the novel progressed I felt he had maybe taken on too many different themes at the same time. 'Nonesuch' is a fantasy novel but it is also an account of the reality of being in London at the start of the war, a history of the development of the war, an exploration of economics and the stock market and a reflection of the possibility of time travel. This results in cliffhanger moments of magical peril being diffused by lengthy passages about the financial markets. Nevertheless, Francis Spufford is always an entertaining, clever writer and 'Nonesuch' is an unusual and enthralling read. The picture he paints of everyday life in London during the Blitz is fascinating, reminding me of 'The Night Watch' by Sarah Waters (reviewed here in January 2008). I look forward to seeing where Francis Spufford turns his attention next.