Edinburgh Festivals 2025

29 August 2025

We had a great time at the Edinburgh Festivals last week, seeing 21 shows across a wide variety of genres, topics and venues. There were many highlights but I'll just mention a few favourites:

'Down to Chance' is a great piece of fringe theatre from the Cornwall-based theatre company Maybe You Like It. A two-hander with Ellie Jay Cooper (also the writer) and Robert Merriam playing multiple roles, it tells the story of the Great Earthquake that hit Anchorage, Alaska, on Good Friday 1964. The earthquake took out all communications apart from the local radio station, where female reporter Genie Chance was left in sole charge, broadcasting through the night to reunite missing people and coordinate the volunteer efforts. A gripping true story, entertainingly told.

'Lady Macbeth Played Wing Defence' by West Australian company Crash Theatre Co. and House of Oz reimagines the Scottish play as the story of a high school netball team. ‘Mac’ is determined to become captain of the team, even if it means dispensing with her teammates by murdering their reputations. It's great fun, and very silly, but the occasional actual Shakespearean speeches are surprisingly moving.
'The Queen Is Mad' is a musical/chamber opera, by Amy Clare Tasker and Tom James McGrath, about Joanna, elder sister of Catherine of Aragon and daughter of Ferdinand and Isabella, who inherited the thrones of Castile and Aragon but was prevented from ruling either by her father, her husband and her son who imprisoned her, claiming she was mad. It's beautifully sung by a cast of three, featuring Maria Coyne as Joanna, and a fascinating piece of history.  

We were very lucky to see the Aurora Orchestra, conducted by Nicholas Collon, at the Usher Hall, playing Shostakovich's 5th Symphony from memory. Memorising this titanic work for a huge orchestra is an incredible feat but it's not just a party trick. The whole orchestra standing, without any music stands, and moving with the music, was an amazing sight. And it sounded fresh and incredibly exciting. They had played the symphony at The Proms in London a few days before and it's well worth watching on BBC iPlayer, but it only gives you a flavour of the live experience. It was a thrilling performance. 

'Origin Story: Shostakovich and Stalin – The Composer and the Dictator'

15 August 2025

2025 is the fiftieth anniversary of the death of the Russian composer Dmitri Shostakovich. I’m currently preparing to take part in a Northampton Symphony Orchestra weekend workshop at the end of August which will see an orchestra of nearly 120 players tackling Shostakovich’s massive ‘Symphony No 4’. And next week I’m going to see the Aurora Orchestra performing Shostakovich’s ‘Symphony No 5’ (from memory) at the Edinburgh International Festival. So I’ve been reading a lot about Shostakovich and the extraordinary challenges he faced as a composer in Joseph Stalin’s Soviet Union. I particularly enjoyed a recent episode of the ‘Origin Story’ podcast on ‘Shostakovich and Stalin – The Composer and the Dictator’. Presenters Dorian Lynskey and Ian Dunt give an overview of Shostakovich’s life in a clear, accessible way which doesn’t require much knowledge of classical music. They refer to Julian Barnes’ novel about Shostakovich, 'The Noise of Time' (which I reviewed here in March 2016) and Armando Iannucci’s 2017 film ‘The Death of Stalin’. They also tell the incredible tale of the first performance of Shostakovich’s ‘Symphony No 7’ in the Leningrad Philharmonic Hall during the siege of Leningrad in 1942, which I learned about when I played the Leningrad Symphony with Northampton Symphony Orchestra in 2013 (reviewed here in November 2013). You can listen to the podcast here.
 

'Harry Potter and the Cursed Child' by Jack Thorne

6 August 2025

On Saturday we were at the Palace Theatre in London's West End to see 'Harry Potter and the Cursed Child' - Jack Thorne's mammoth theatrical realisation of 'what happened next' to Harry, Ron and Hermione, based on an original story by Jack Thorne, J. K. Rowling, and John Tiffany. Split into two full-length plays (each around 2 hours 40 minutes long) it requires a significant commitment. One review called it "not so much a play as a weekend mini-break, a theatrical experience that lasts longer than some relationships". We saw both parts on the same day (with a meal in between) and returned to the same seats in the evening to see almost all of our neighbours had done the same. I liked that the stage show was a conventional play - not a musical, no need to break the fourth wall or make it a play about putting on a Harry Potter play etc. And the magic was stunningly realised without any digital technology or projection, just old fashioned stage effects which created some wondrous 'wow' moments. John Tiffany's production has a large cast who are all very strong. Excellent movement choreographed by Stephen Hoggett and a clever set by Christine Jones combine to create beautiful balletic scenes around two sets of staircases on wheels which swirl around the stage causing characters to just miss each other. The plays have an incredibly complicated plot which does require knowledge of the Harry Potter books - particularly 'Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire'. But it was actually surprisingly easy to follow and was a very enjoyable and entertaining tale with some unexpected twists. 'Harry Potter and the Cursed Child' has been running in London for nine years and it was interesting to see that the audience seemed to be mostly adults. There was one lovely moment towards the end of the evening when a particularly serious and poignant scene involving two parents discussing their concern for their son ended with the couple movingly parting with a kiss, prompting a young voice in a row just behind us to loudly exclaim "eww!" causing great laughter around us - and confusion across the rest of the auditorium.  

Tom Robinson

6 August 2025

On Friday we were at Esquires - a small live music venue in Bedford - to see the Tom Robinson Band. We've seen Tom Robinson so many times that we don't just know all the songs, we know all the stories he tells about them and have to restrain ourselves from spoiling the punchlines. But we still love seeing him perform and Tom and the band (including excellent new drummer Siân Monaghan) were on top form last weekend. It always surprises us how many people cheer when he asks if there is anyone in the crowd who hasn't seen him before. It's wonderful to see him continuing to grow his fanbase at the age of 75. And each time we see him I am reminded what a good songwriter Tom Robinson is, and what an extensive back catalogue of songs he has to draw on. 

'The Winter's Tale' by William Shakespeare

1 August 2025

On Saturday we were at the Royal Shakespeare Theatre in Stratford-upon-Avon to see the new RSC production of 'The Winter's Tale', directed by Yaël Farber, with Bertie Carvel as Leontes. Soutra Gilmour's stark set features a large dominant moon overhead, constantly changing its colour and features, and a shallow trench of water around the three edges of the stage through which many of the characters paddle. It is also the first time I have seen a stage with two separate revolves. This is a thoughtful, serious production that explores the classical and folkloric origins of Shakespeare's story. Trevor Fox plays 'Time The Thief' - an additional ever-present background character who contributes songs and poetry to the play, as well as giving Time's speech at the start of Act 4 (to explain that 16 years have passed) and playing Autolycus. While this was a clever device it did make the scenes with Autolycus - which usually provide great comic relief - less funny. Overall this is a high quality production but I felt it didn't always manage to convey the complexities of the plot clearly enough. 'The Winter's Tale' can be a slightly awkward disjointed play of two halves but I think it works best with a more playful approach - such as Edward Halls's glorious Propeller production which we saw in Canterbury many years ago (reviewed here in April 2012) which featured singing sheep (‘The Bleatles’) and beatboxing shepherds. 

'Arms and the Man' by George Bernard Shaw

1 August 2025

At Easter this year we visited Shaw's Corner - the house where George Bernard Shaw lived, with his wife Charlotte, in the pretty Hertfordshire village of Ayot St Lawrence. Now a National Trust property, Shaw's Corner provides a fascinating insight into the life of the first person to win both an Oscar and a Nobel prize (both of which are on display in the house). While we were there we noticed that Shaw's Corner was going to host an open-air production of one of Shaw's plays to mark the weekend of the playwright's birthday in July. So last Friday we returned to Ayot St Lawrence to see the Rumpus Theatre Company performing 'Arms and the Man' against the backdrop of Shaw's house. I had seen 'Arms and the Man' twice before, including a great production at the Intiman Theatre in Seattle in 2002. It sits in a line of genteel but subversive comedy that stretches from Jane Austen via Oscar Wilde to Alan Ayckbourn. When it was first performed in 1894 it was billed as an 'anti-romantic comedy' but there is something romantically charming about Shaw's removal of the artifice of manners and performative chivalry. The play also deals with the realities of war and soldiering, albeit through civilised drawing-room discussion rather than actual fighting. The Rumpus production, directed and designed by John Goodrum - who also played The Man - was great fun. The strong cast managed to convey both the apparent comic caricature of the characters and the realistic sympathetic people behind the masks their positions require. And Shaw's Corner was a lovely setting on a beautiful sunny summer evening.